SGC-WH-UNI-039 · Research edition September 8, 2026
174 Center Street, southwest corner of Center Street and Union Avenue, West Haven. The 1940 directory gives 176 Center Street. Includes the Union district and earlier school buildings, with the present landmark and senior-housing reuse distinguished.
Executive history
Union School’s surviving brick building dates to 1890, but the institution’s story begins earlier. The 1940 town history records that classes formerly held on the Green were consolidated with Union Avenue School in 1849. It describes a two-room wooden school with a belfry, bell, and chain pump at Union Avenue and Center Street before 1860, followed by other wooden schoolhouses. These predecessors should not be illustrated with a photograph of the later brick school without an explanation. The shared name links a succession of buildings and educational arrangements, not one structure of unchanging age. [WH-UNI-001]
The new school was planned while West Haven remained part of Orange. The National Register nomination reports that 538 of Orange’s 849 pupils belonged to the Union district in 1889. Space, light, ventilation, and fire resistance drove the building program, concerns sharpened by a schoolhouse fire that year. Architect Leoni W. Robinson designed the two-story brick school, with terra-cotta and red-sandstone trim, a tower, and an arched entrance. Its ten classrooms were each intended for fifty pupils. The building’s prominence made education a visible civic investment. [WH-UNI-007]
The earlier school experience differed markedly from that modernizing ambition. The 1940 history says pupils furnished their own books and materials and used slates in place of paper and pencil; summer as well as winter terms were held. Its account also shows why the Union School District must be distinguished from Union School itself. In 1899 the district contained four schoolhouses and more than a thousand children of school age. Governance changed from school visitors to a district Board of Education, before the town’s separate districts were consolidated in 1926. [WH-UNI-008][WH-UNI-001][WH-UNI-002]
Union housed both grammar-school and high-school pupils. The high-school course lengthened over time, and the high-school community eventually moved to the Main Street building in 1927. Union’s rear addition, dated approximately 1914 in the National Register, closely followed the original design. The later nomination records its adaptation to senior housing and identifies the property at 174 Center Street. The 1940 directory used 176 Center Street; the archival address should be retained as a variant, not substituted for the later legal identification. [WH-UNI-007][WH-UNI-008][WH-UNI-009]
Surviving class photographs can restore the people to this building history. The Historical Society identifies Union photographs dated 1924 and 1944, including a later group attributed in the image to Pack Brothers. These are valuable source leads, but their public display is not a reproduction license. The cleared documents in this initial collection support the institutional chronology; they do not claim to replace the missing licensed class images. An original opening program, a precise final school day, and the full chronology of the senior-housing conversion remain gaps for further archival work. [WH-UNI-003]
Key dates
1849 — Classes from the former school on the Green were consolidated with Union Avenue School. WH-UNI-001
Before 1860 — A two-room wooden Union School stood at Union Avenue and Center Street. WH-UNI-001
1889–1890 — Surviving brick Union School constructed; it opened in 1890. WH-UNI-007
1899 — Union School District had four schoolhouses; district governance reorganized under a Board of Education. WH-UNI-008
c. 1914 — Rear addition expanded the brick school. WH-UNI-007
1924 — Date of a Union class photograph in the Historical Society gallery. WH-UNI-003
1927-02-07 — High-school community moved into the new Main Street high school. WH-UNI-010
1944 — Date of a later Union class photograph in the Historical Society gallery. WH-UNI-003
By 1987 — Former school was in use as senior housing when nominated to the National Register. WH-UNI-007
1987-11-13 — Union School entered the National Register. WH-UNI-005
A closer look at the surviving record
A wooden school before the landmark
The town history recalls the belfry, bell, slates, and chain pump of an earlier Union School. The 1890 brick landmark belongs to a later chapter.
The lower section of printed page 64 traces the Union, Northern, and Western districts and their consolidation in 1926. A district boundary and a school building are different historical subjects.
Includes source text where acquired. Source websites require an internet connection. OCR may contain errors; verify names and dates against the scan.
10 catalog entries
No matching items. Try fewer words or another spelling.
WH-UNI-001 · Historical documents · 1940
Union School’s early buildings and school life
Printed page 63 describes earlier Union schoolhouses and the consolidation of classes formerly held on the Green.
Public domain in the United States: repository states that copyright was not renewed, citing the Stanford renewal database. No separate copyright notice appears on the selected plate. Full printed page retained. Scan quality reflects the photocopied source; OCR may contain errors.
History of West Haven, Connecticut (1940)
PDF page 177
Source: https://archive.org/download/historyofwesthav00unse/historyofwesthav00unse.pdf#page=177
EDUCATION
First mention of a schoolhouse in West Haven is contained in the records
of the Ecclesiastical Society of the First Congregational Church. In 1742.
money was raised by the sale of town lands, and it was voted that the amount
of 328 pounds, 5 shillings, 10 pence be approved for the year for the support of
the school “until the end of time, unless the government ordered to the contrary”.
According to the Jurisdiction Records of 1661, a schoolmaster of the period
was paid a total of 60 pounds per annum, the majority of these payments being
made as follows: 30 bushels of wheat, 2 barrels of pork, 2 barrels of beef, 40
bushels of Indian corn, 30 bushels of pease, 2 firkins of butter, 1 (X) pounds of
ilax, and 30 bushels of general foods.
As the population of the village increased, additional school facilities were
needed. In 1805, the Southern District urged the erection of a new school-
house on the Green, but it was “voated” not to build the proposed school on
this location. That vote was evidently reconsidered, and the building was auth¬
orized, “in any place around the Green within forty feet of the line of the
squair”. Erected in that same year, the building was still standing on the Green
in 1857 but was not in use after 1849, when the classes were consolidated with
those of the Union Avenue School.
Union School
For many years prior to 1860, Union School, a two-room wooden structure
with a graceful belfry and bell, and a noisy chain water pump, stood on the
plot of land at Union Avenue and Center Stret, where the present brick Union
School now stands. During the 1880’s, three wooden schools successively stood
on this site. English, Latin, astronomy, and algebra were among the subjects
taught; all materials, including text books, were furnished by the students.
Slates were used instead of paper and pencil.
For several decades after 1860, summer as well as winter terms were held.
In 1891, the salary of a teacher, Dealer M. Smith, is recorded as $76 for a
summer term. The cost of operating Union School for that entire year
was $392.60.
Walden sE School
Another link in West Haven’s early system of education was the little
Waldense School, at Morgan Lane and Benham Hill, established in the Western
District in 1829. This typical country school was at first supported by a dozen
families, each household in turn sharing the responsibility of boarding the
teacher. Two instructors were annually employed, a female instructor for a
period of five months, starting with the first of May, and a male teacher for
four months, starting after Thanksgiving.
Credit: Writers’ Program (U.S.), Connecticut, History of West Haven, Connecticut (Church Press, 1940); Allen County Public Library Genealogy Center / Internet Archive. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-001, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-002 · Historical documents · 1940
The district system and its 1926 consolidation
Printed page 64 includes the School Districts section; the upper portion continues the separate Waldense School account.
Public domain in the United States: repository states that copyright was not renewed, citing the Stanford renewal database. No separate copyright notice appears on the selected plate. Full printed page retained. Scan quality reflects the photocopied source; OCR may contain errors.
History of West Haven, Connecticut (1940)
PDF page 179
Source: https://archive.org/download/historyofwesthav00unse/historyofwesthav00unse.pdf#page=179
Hi STORY OF WEST HAVEN
To maintain the Waldense School, in 1829, the Western School District
levied a tax of nine cents on the dollar, and gave each proprietor the privilege of
paying one-half the tax in timber and labor; timber was valued at the appraisal
of the carpenter, and labor at “6 cents an hour when called by the committee for
the same”.
The original building was 15^4x30x9 feet. A second Waldense School
erected several years later was 20x30x12 feet, and covered with pine boards
at the sides. As protection against the cold winds of winter, there were no win¬
dows on the north side of the building. On the other sides were five tiny win¬
dows, with 3x5 “lights”; the underpinning was laid in lime mortar.
A vote of the school district was required to “set up” school for the two
terms, and parents of each scholar over 4 and under 16 years of age were taxed
according to the number of days the pupil attended school. The district cus¬
tomarily ruled that “No Scholars Shall Be Entitled To Free Money That Are
Over 16 And Shall Bay Their Tax”. In 1839, the school district voted a teach¬
er's salary of $1.75 a week, and estimated the cost of board at $1.25 per week,
“each one having the privilege to board his part as near as can”. A vote was
also taken to designate those who should furnish the cord wood for fuel, and
the price was stipulated at $7.25 per cord for walnut wood, cut to fit the stove.
The school was governed by a district committee of one member, whose
duties consisted of general supervision, hiring the teacher, and purchasing the
fuel. At a school district meeting on March 6, 1871, hesitancy was shown in
allowing one week’s vacation during the summer term, the vote in favor being
qualified, “if, and when the committee shall deem it for the interest of the school”.
The perplexing question at a district meeting on July 14, 1879, was the
teacher’s irregularity in starting school in the morning; as a result, E. E. Ben-
ham was named to superintend the commencing of school. Teachers were paid
$7 per week at that time and sessions were held in summer, fall, and winter.
As larger quarters were necessary in 1897, the district school committee
sold the little building to John Lyman, who commandeered 11 pair of oxen to
move the structure over rough roads to 311 Savin Avenue, where it is now in
use as a dwelling. During that summer a new school, 30 x 40 feet, was erected.
Operation of this little district school came to an end in 1920, when the pupils
were transferred to the Colonial Park School. On August 29, 1925, the school
building went under the auctioneer’s hammer and was sold to James H. Mills.
This old school also is now in use as a residence.
School, Districts
In 1845, there were four school districts in the town of Orange, and by 1874
the number had doubled. Of these, three were in West Haven; Union, North¬
ern, and Western districts; they functioned as individual districts until consoli¬
dated in 1926. Since then, the town schools have been operated as a single dis¬
trict.
64
Credit: Writers’ Program (U.S.), Connecticut, History of West Haven, Connecticut (Church Press, 1940); Allen County Public Library Genealogy Center / Internet Archive. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-002, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-003 · Sources & research leads · 1924
Union School class photograph, 1924
The Historical Society identifies an authentic class group as Union School, 1924.
No explicit reuse license or original publication evidence. Direct image: https://whhistoricalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/photo-gallery/imported_from_media_libray/Union_School-1924.jpg External source reference; the complete source is not reproduced in this download.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-003, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-004 · Sources & research leads · 1944
Union School class photograph, 1944
A group portrait labeled Union School 1944, with Pack Brothers credit visible in the image.
Copyright not cleared; source link only. Direct image: https://whhistoricalsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/photo-gallery/imported_from_media_libray/Union_School_1944.jpg External source reference; the complete source is not reproduced in this download.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-004, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-005 · Sources & research leads · 1987
National Register nomination and photo set
Original architectural nomination and accompanying photographs document the building and senior-housing conversion.
Third-party consultant survey material; no blanket federal public-domain assumption. External source reference; the complete source is not reproduced in this download.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-005, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-006 · Sources & research leads · 2014-07-23
Modern building photograph and architectural overview
Architectural overview distinguishes the 1890 building, earlier wooden structures, and 1914 addition.
Modern photograph not cleared for local reproduction. External source reference; the complete source is not reproduced in this download.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-006, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-007 · Sources & research leads · Undated
Coverage gaps
No cleared Union class photograph or exterior image is included. Exact last school day and senior-housing conversion completion date were not verified.
The 1940 history’s internally contradictory 1899/1890 early-high-school sentence is not used to establish the high school’s founding year. External source reference; the complete source is not reproduced in this download.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-007, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-008 · Sources & research leads · Source consulted September 2026
Supporting source: archive.org
Supporting source for the collection history and chronology.
External source; consult the original publication for its full context.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-008, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-009 · Sources & research leads · Source consulted September 2026
Supporting source: archive.org
Supporting source for the collection history and chronology.
External source; consult the original publication for its full context.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-009, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.
WH-UNI-010 · Sources & research leads · Source consulted September 2026
Supporting source: npgallery.nps.gov
Supporting source for the collection history and chronology.
External source; consult the original publication for its full context.
Credit: Original publisher or holding institution, linked at source. Cite SGC SGC-WH-UNI-039, WH-UNI-010, source title, page and URL; accessed September 8, 2026.